I’ll admit something: I’ve been making pizza dough from scratch for years, and I still keep a stack of Totino’s Party Pizzas in the freezer. They’re cheap, they’re nostalgic, and when someone in my house yells “I’m hungry” at 9 PM on a Tuesday, they’re exactly what the moment calls for.

But cooking them in a conventional oven? That’s 20+ minutes of preheating for a pizza that costs a dollar fifty. The air fryer changes the entire equation. You go from frozen to crispy in under 10 minutes, no preheat, and the crust comes out better than the oven ever managed.

I didn’t stop at Totino’s, though. I tested five more frozen pizza brands in the air fryer to figure out the exact time and temperature for each one — because the internet kept giving me conflicting answers and I got tired of guessing. Here’s everything I found.

The Quick Answer

That’s the short version. If all you needed was the number, you’re good to go. But if you want to know how I landed on those settings — or what happens when you throw a Red Baron or DiGiorno in there instead — keep reading.

Why the Air Fryer Beats the Oven for Frozen Pizza

The conventional oven instructions on a Totino’s box tell you to bake at 450°F for 12–15 minutes. That doesn’t include the 10–15 minutes of preheating. So you’re looking at 25+ minutes total for a pizza that’s roughly the size of a vinyl record.

The air fryer skips all of that. Its compact chamber and rapid-circulation fan mean the heating element is inches from your pizza, not feet. As Taste of Home explains, an air fryer is essentially a small convection oven — the hot air wraps around the crust from every angle, which is exactly why the bottom gets crispy instead of staying limp and pale like it sometimes does on a baking sheet.

Three reasons I prefer this method over the oven:

• Speed. Seven minutes from freezer to plate. No preheat. If you’ve got kids losing their patience, this is the move.
• Crispier crust. The circulating air dries the surface faster, which gives you that crunch that a pizza stone or steel would normally handle on a from-scratch pie.
• No heating up the kitchen. On a hot summer day, firing up the oven for a Totino’s feels like punishment. The air fryer barely raises the room temperature.

How to Cook Totino’s Pizza in the Air Fryer (Step by Step)

This is about as simple as cooking gets, but a couple of small details make the difference between “pretty good” and genuinely crispy.

Step 1: Remove the Totino’s Party Pizza from its packaging. Don’t thaw it — straight from the freezer is what you want. Thawed frozen pizza gets soggy before the crust has a chance to crisp. (The USDA also recommends cooking frozen foods directly from frozen for best quality.)

Step 2: Place the pizza flat in the air fryer basket, crust side down. Totino’s square-ish shape fits surprisingly well in most basket-style air fryers (5-quart and up). If you’re using an air fryer oven, place it on the middle rack.

Step 3: Set to 400°F and cook for 6–8 minutes. No preheat needed. Start checking at the 6-minute mark — you’re looking for cheese that’s fully melted and starting to bubble, with edges that have gone golden brown.

Step 4: Use a spatula to remove the pizza (it’s hot — resist the urge to grab it). Let it rest for about 60 seconds before cutting. This isn’t just a safety thing — the cheese firms up slightly during that rest, which makes slicing cleaner.

That’s it. The smoke detector did not go off, which in my kitchen qualifies as a roaring success.

5 More Frozen Brands Tested: The Complete Chart

Totino’s is the one everyone asks about, but it’s not the only frozen pizza that fits in an air fryer. I tested five more popular brands to find the right temp and time for each. All tests used a 5.8-quart basket-style air fryer, no preheat, cooking from frozen.

Here’s what I found:

A few patterns jumped out. Thin-crust pizzas (Totino’s, Celeste) do best at 400°F with shorter cook times. Thicker crusts (DiGiorno rising crust, Tombstone) need 380°F and a few extra minutes so the interior cooks through before the toppings burn. If your air fryer runs hot — and some definitely do — drop the temp by 10°F across the board and add a minute.

Why Results Vary Between Brands

It comes down to three things: crust thickness, topping density, and moisture content. A Totino’s Party Pizza has a paper-thin crust with a light scatter of toppings — there’s very little mass for the air fryer to heat through. A DiGiorno rising crust is the opposite: thick, yeasty dough with heavier toppings that insulate the center.

More mass means more time. More moisture means you need lower heat to avoid burning the surface before the middle is done. That’s the whole secret, and it applies to any frozen food you reheat in the air fryer.

The Oven-to-Air Fryer Conversion Formula

If your favorite frozen pizza isn’t on the chart above, you can convert the box instructions yourself. The formula is simple and works for just about any brand. Allrecipes’ air fryer conversion guide confirms the same general rule:

So if you’ve got a frozen pizza with box instructions of 450°F for 12 minutes, set your air fryer to 425°F and start checking around 7 minutes. It’s not perfectly precise — every air fryer model is a little different — but it’ll get you in the right neighborhood every time. From there, you learn your machine by checking a minute early until you dial it in.

This same formula works for air fryer tortilla pizzas and French bread pizza, by the way. Just adjust for thickness.

Troubleshooting: Burnt Edges, Soggy Centers & Cheese Slides

The air fryer is forgiving, but frozen pizza can still go sideways. Here are the three most common problems and how to fix them.

Burnt or Charred Edges

This happens when the pizza is too close to the heating element or the temp is too high for the crust type. Fix: drop the temperature by 10–15°F and add a minute. Also make sure the pizza is centered in the basket — edges that touch the sides or curl upward will catch heat directly and char.

Soggy or Undercooked Center

Common with rising-crust and thick-crust brands. The outside looks done, but the middle is still doughy. Fix: lower the temperature to 370–380°F and extend the time. The goal is giving the center enough time to cook through without the cheese going volcanic on top. If your air fryer has an air fry oven setting, use the middle rack to get more even heat distribution.

Cheese Sliding Off

This usually means the pizza shifted during cooking or the air fryer’s fan is strong enough to move lightweight toppings. Fix: place the pizza flat and centered, don’t tilt the basket during cooking, and avoid opening the drawer too aggressively mid-cook. The 60-second rest after cooking also helps — as The Kitchn notes, resting lets the cheese re-firm and stops it from migrating.

Pro Tips for the Crispiest Frozen Pizza

Watch: Totino’s Party Pizza in the Air Fryer

This video walks you through the entire process. It’s about as complicated as opening a bag and pressing a button — which is exactly the kind of recipe I respect on a weeknight.

Frequently Asked Questions

Look, nobody’s claiming a Totino’s from the air fryer will rival a homemade New York slice or a proper Neapolitan pie. But for a quick, cheap, zero-effort meal that’s ready before the delivery app even processes your order? The air fryer makes frozen pizza genuinely good.

Set it to 400°F, give it 7 minutes, and move on with your evening. That’s the whole recipe.

Keep Reading