Regional Pizza Styles: 5 American Pies You’ve (Probably) Never Heard Of

Regional Styles · The Deep Cuts

Regional Pizza Styles: 5 American Pies You’ve Probably Never Heard Of

Cold cheese on hot pizza. American cheese on purpose. Crusts you dip in honey. Meet the small-town pies that never made the national argument.

Every pizza debate in America eventually collapses into New York versus Chicago. Somebody folds a slice, somebody else calls deep dish a casserole, and everyone goes home angry.

Meanwhile, out in coal towns, river towns and mountain towns, people have been quietly eating pizzas that would break both camps’ brains. Some of these pies put the cheese on after the bake. One uses American cheese on purpose. One skips cheese entirely and gets eaten at room temperature.

I haven’t road-tripped to all five of these places (yet), so I went looking at what the pizzerias, families and trade press behind each style actually say. Here are five American regional pizza styles worth knowing, what makes each one tick, and how to get a taste of them in your own kitchen.

Key Takeaways

  • Old Forge, Pennsylvania bakes rectangular “trays” with secret cheese blends and calls itself the Pizza Capital of the World.
  • Altoona-style stacks salami and green peppers under a blanket of American cheese on a thick Sicilian-style crust.
  • Ohio Valley-style adds cold, hand-grated provolone and cold toppings after the pizza comes out of the oven.
  • Colorado mountain pie has a honey-sweetened, rolled edge built to hold a mountain of toppings, and it’s sold by the pound.
  • Rhode Island pizza strips are cheeseless, saucy bakery squares served at room temperature.

Why Regional Pizza Styles Exist at All

Most regional pizza styles in the US started the same way: one shop, one family, one quirk that the town decided it loved. The quirk usually came from practical stuff, like the pans on hand, the cheese the local wholesaler stocked, or what kept well on a bakery counter.

Then the neighbors copied it, the town claimed it, and nobody outside the county noticed for fifty years. That’s the story behind the big names too. Our guide to popular pizza styles explained covers Neapolitan, New York, Chicago, Detroit and the rest of the headliners.

This list is the B-side. We’ve already dug into a few cult favorites on their own, including St. Louis pizza and its Provel cheese, the sauce-on-top Trenton tomato pie, and Buffalo’s cup-and-char pepperoni pie. The five below are even deeper cuts.

1. Old Forge Pizza (Old Forge, Pennsylvania)

Old Forge is a former coal-mining town of about 8,300 people in northeast Pennsylvania, and it has given itself a modest title: the Pizza Capital of the World. According to PMQ Pizza Magazine’s deep dive on Old Forge, the town’s pizza history goes back to at least 1926, when the matriarch of the Ghigiarelli family started serving pizza to coal miners at the family tavern.

She baked those pies in rectangular metal pans, and the pans stuck. Other shops copied the format and added their own twists, and today the rectangle is the whole identity.

What makes it different

The crust is breadlike, with a chewy center and a crisp bottom. Some pizzerias slide the pie out of its pan onto the oven’s brick at the end to crisp the base. The sauce runs slightly sweet and chunky, with a noticeable onion flavor.

The cheese is the real mystery. Every shop guards its own blend, and local pizza reviewer Jim Mirabelli told PMQ that “the cheese blend is the big secret.” His educated guess is a mix that may include processed cheese, cheddar, American and possibly brick, but nobody’s confirming anything.

Learn the lingo

Order like a local: a whole pie is a tray, and a piece is a cut. There’s also a white Old Forge pizza with dough on the top and bottom and the cheese and fillings sealed in the middle, closer to a double-crust pie than anything you’d call pizza elsewhere.

Home cook’s shortcut: Bake a well-oiled rectangular pan pie, use a sauce with sauteed onion cooked into it, and blend a little cheddar and American into your mozzarella. Our beginner sheet pan pizza method is a solid base to start from.

2. Altoona-Style Pizza (Altoona, Pennsylvania)

If Old Forge is mysterious, Altoona-style is just plain controversial. It started at the Altoona Hotel in central Pennsylvania in the 1950s, according to the Altoona-style pizza entry on Wikipedia, which pulls from local and Pittsburgh press coverage.

The build goes like this: a thick, soft Sicilian-style crust, tomato sauce, sliced green bell pepper, deli-style salami studded with peppercorns, and then yellow American cheese on top instead of mozzarella or provolone. The original reportedly used Velveeta. It gets cut into squares.

The hotel burned down in 2013, and other local restaurants picked up the style afterward. Food writers love to argue about whether it counts as pizza at all, and honestly, a pizza that makes purists clutch their pearls is a pizza I want to know more about. FYI, if you grew up on school-cafeteria rectangle pizza, Altoona-style might taste weirdly like home.

Home cook’s shortcut: Press a thick pan dough into a 9-by-13 pan, sauce it, layer thin salami and green pepper rings, then cover the whole thing with slices of deli American cheese. Our grandma pizza guide has the pan technique you need.

3. Ohio Valley-Style Pizza (Steubenville, Ohio)

This is the one that makes people angry on the internet. Ohio Valley pizza gets its cheese and toppings after the bake, and they go on cold. The heat of the crust and the steam in the box do the rest.

The style traces back to the DiCarlo family of Steubenville, Ohio, who ran an Italian grocery that turned into a bakery. As PMQ’s history of Ohio Valley-style pizza tells it, their son Primo came home from World War II talking about the pizza he’d had in Italy and opened the Original DiCarlo’s Famous Pizza Shop in 1945. A second shop followed in Wheeling, West Virginia, in 1949.

How it’s built

The thick crust bakes on a sheet pan with sauce. It comes out, gets more sauce and a light layer of cheese, then goes back in. When it’s golden, the cooks pile on cold, hand-grated aged provolone and the toppings, and the pie is sold by the square.

Why cold? Granddaughter Anna DiCarlo told PMQ it’s simply “the way we’ve always done it,” though she suggested the thick pans of the old days may have burned cheese added before baking. The result is a contrast you don’t get anywhere else: crisp, hot crust against cool, sharp, barely softened provolone.

Home cook’s shortcut: This one is the easiest of the five to make at home, which is why it gets the full recipe below.

Every pizza rule you think is universal, from hot cheese to round pies to mozzarella, is just a habit somebody’s town never picked up.

4. Colorado Mountain Pie (Idaho Springs, Colorado)

Colorado’s contribution comes from one restaurant: Beau Jo’s, in the mountain town of Idaho Springs. The chain’s own explainer on the Colorado Mountain Pie dates the first one to 1973 and credits a founder named Pete ZaPigh.

Say that name out loud. Yes, it’s a joke, and PMQ confirms the legend is tongue-in-cheek. I respect a restaurant that commits to a bit for fifty years.

The real story, per PMQ’s profile of Beau Jo’s, is that Chip Bair bought the shop from its previous owners in 1973 for $8,500. When food prices rose, the kitchen piled on more toppings, and a waitress named Patsy May started rolling the edges of the dough to keep everything from sliding off.

Honey in the crust, honey on the table

An employee swapped the sugar in the dough for honey, and another started drizzling honey on the crust. Now honey sits on every table for dipping the thick, rolled edge, which turns the crust into dessert by the end of the meal.

These pies are heavy enough that Beau Jo’s sells them by weight. A small weighs a pound, and the sizes climb from there. The company now runs six locations around Colorado.

Home cook’s shortcut: Use honey instead of sugar in your dough, leave a wide border, and roll that border inward into a thick rope before topping heavily. Serve with a jar of honey on the side and see who reaches for it first.

5. Rhode Island Pizza Strips (Providence, Rhode Island)

Walk into an old Italian bakery in Rhode Island and you’ll find stacks of rectangular strips wrapped in wax paper, sitting on the counter. They have a focaccia-like crust, a thick layer of red tomato sauce, and no cheese. Locals also call them red strips, party pizza or bakery pizza.

According to Red Sauce America’s history of Rhode Island pizza strips, the first ones were made from leftover bread dough baked on a sheet. Nobody seems willing to name the inventor, but the tradition grew out of the Italian bakeries of Providence’s Federal Hill neighborhood in the early 1900s.

Why there’s no cheese

The early strips did have cheese. But they sat on the counter all day at room temperature, and health officials objected to dairy left out like that. Rather than buy refrigeration, the bakeries dropped the cheese. The sauce became the star, and the strips became a grab-and-go lunch for construction and factory workers.

You buy them by the strip or by the whole tray. Some bakeries now sell refrigerated “white strips” with cheese, but the red ones are the classic.

Home cook’s shortcut: Bake a thin layer of dough in an oiled sheet pan, cover it with a thick, well-seasoned sauce, and let it cool before cutting into strips. Our recipe for focaccia from pizza dough gets you the right crumb, and this is a great way to use leftover pizza dough, exactly like the bakeries did.

The Five Side by Side

Here’s the cheat sheet. Notice how often the shape is a rectangle and the cut is a square. Small-town America clearly trusted sheet pans more than pizza peels.

StyleHome baseShape and cutCrustCheeseThe weird part
Old ForgeOld Forge, PARectangular tray, sold by the cutBreadlike, chewy, crisp bottomSecret house blendOniony sauce and a double-crust white version
AltoonaAltoona, PAPan pie, cut in squaresThick, soft, Sicilian-styleAmerican cheese (once Velveeta)Salami and green peppers under the cheese
Ohio ValleySteubenville, OHSheet pan, sold by the squareThick, baked twice with sauceCold aged provolone, added after bakingCold toppings on a hot pie
Colorado mountain pieIdaho Springs, CORound, sold by the poundHoney dough, thick rolled edgeHeavy, under heaps of toppingsHoney for dipping the crust
Rhode Island stripsProvidence, RISheet pan, cut in stripsFocaccia-likeNone on the classic red stripEaten at room temperature

When Each Style Showed Up

Five regional pies, in order of arrival190019401980Early 1900sRI pizza stripsBy 1926Old Forge trays1945Ohio Valley, DiCarlo's1950sAltoona Hotel1973Colorado mountain pieThree of the five bake in rectangles. None of them asked New York for permission.

Dates from Red Sauce America (Rhode Island strips), PMQ Pizza Magazine (Old Forge, Ohio Valley, Colorado) and Wikipedia’s Altoona-style pizza entry. The Rhode Island inventor and exact year are unrecorded, so that marker is approximate.

Tips for Cooking Regional Styles at Home

Get a real sheet pan. A heavy, rimmed half sheet handles Old Forge, Ohio Valley and Rhode Island strips. Oil it generously so the bottom fries a little.

Grate your own cheese. Especially for Ohio Valley, where the cheese never melts much. Pre-shredded bags carry anti-caking starch that makes cold cheese taste dusty.

Season the sauce harder. On cheeseless strips and lightly cheesed pies, the sauce carries the flavor. Start from a good homemade pizza sauce and taste it on bread first.

Bake low in the oven. Pan pies need bottom heat. The lowest rack at 475°F to 500°F gets the base crisp before the top overbrowns.

If these thick pan styles hook you, the logical next stops are our Detroit-style pizza at home walkthrough and the cracker-thin opposite end of the spectrum, Chicago tavern-style pizza. New England fans should also check our Greek-style oiled-pan pie and bar style pizza with cheddar to the rim.

Try One Tonight: Ohio Valley-Style Pizza at Home

Ohio Valley-Style Sheet Pan Pizza (Cold Provolone, Hot Crust)

This is a home-oven take on the Steubenville pie: a thick sheet pan crust baked twice with sauce, then finished with a heap of cold, freshly grated provolone and cold pepperoni. I built it from the method DiCarlo’s describes rather than any shop’s exact formula, and I haven’t baked it side by side with the real thing, so treat the times as your starting point. The first bite is a genuine head-scratcher in the best way.

  • Star ingredient: aged provolone, grated cold
  • Flavor: sharp, tangy, salty, crisp-bottomed
  • Best for: parties, game day, anyone who says they’ve tried every pizza
  • Difficulty: easy
Prep25 min
Rise2 hr 45 min
Cook20–25 min
Total3 hr 35 min
Oven475°F
MakesOne half sheet, 12 squares

Dough

  • 3¼ cups (400 grams) bread flour
  • 1 cup plus 3 tablespoons (280 grams) lukewarm water
  • 1½ teaspoons fine sea salt
  • 1 teaspoon instant yeast
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil, plus 3 tablespoons for the pan

Sauce

  • 1½ cups canned crushed tomatoes
  • 1 small garlic clove, finely grated
  • 1 teaspoon sugar
  • ½ teaspoon dried oregano
  • ½ teaspoon salt

Cheese and Toppings

  • 2 ounces low-moisture mozzarella, shredded (for the light baked layer)
  • 8 ounces aged provolone, grated cold from the fridge (about 2 cups)
  • 3 ounces sliced pepperoni, kept cold

Why aged provolone? It’s the cheese DiCarlo’s uses, and its sharp, tangy bite tastes good even unmelted. Mild deli provolone works, but it tastes flatter served cold. Grate it straight from the fridge so it stays fluffy.

Instructions

  1. Mix the flour, salt and yeast in a large bowl. Add the water and 1 tablespoon oil and stir until no dry flour remains. Knead 6 to 8 minutes until smooth and slightly tacky.
  2. Cover and let rise at room temperature about 2 hours, until roughly doubled and bubbly on top.
  3. Pour 3 tablespoons olive oil onto a rimmed half sheet pan (about 18 by 13 inches). Press the dough toward the corners. If it fights back, rest it 15 minutes and press again. Cover and proof about 45 minutes, until puffy.
  4. Heat the oven to 475°F with a rack in the lowest position. Stir the sauce ingredients together. Spread about half the sauce thinly over the dough.
  5. Bake 12 to 14 minutes, until the crust is set and the edges are just turning golden.
  6. Pull the pan, spread the rest of the sauce, and scatter the mozzarella in a thin layer. Bake another 8 to 10 minutes, until the bottom is deep golden and crisp when you lift a corner with a spatula and the edges smell toasty.
  7. Cut into 12 squares right in the pan. Immediately pile the cold provolone generously over every square, then add the cold pepperoni on top.
  8. Lay a sheet of foil loosely over the pan for 1 to 2 minutes so the steam softens the cheese slightly, the way the pizza box does at the shop. Serve right away while the crust is hot and the cheese is still cool.

Tips: If the top browns before the bottom crisps, set the pan directly on the oven floor for the last 3 minutes. Keep the provolone in the fridge until the second the pizza comes out, because the contrast is the whole point.

Variation: Add cold banana peppers or thin-sliced raw green pepper along with the pepperoni. Or go full Altoona-curious and finish half the pan with cold provolone and the other half with salami and pepper under melted American cheese, then make your family vote.

Take the first bite and pay attention to the temperature change. That’s Steubenville.

FAQ

What are regional pizza styles?

They’re pizzas tied to a specific city or area, usually traced back to one pizzeria or family whose quirk caught on locally. New York and Chicago are the famous ones, but dozens of smaller towns have their own, from Old Forge trays to Colorado mountain pies.

Which of these regional styles is easiest to make at home?

Ohio Valley-style and Rhode Island pizza strips. Both bake on a regular sheet pan, need no special cheese melting skills, and forgive a home oven’s lower heat. Altoona-style is easy too, as long as you’re at peace with American cheese.

Why does Ohio Valley pizza use cold cheese?

The DiCarlo family says it’s simply how they’ve always done it, possibly because the heavy pans of the 1940s scorched cheese added before baking. The hot crust and the steam in the box soften the cheese just a little.

What do you call a slice of Old Forge pizza?

A cut. A whole pie is a tray. Old Forge pizzerias sell red trays with sauce and cheese and white versions with dough on both top and bottom.

Why don’t Rhode Island pizza strips have cheese?

They used to. Bakeries kept the strips on the counter at room temperature all day, health officials objected to dairy sitting out, and the bakeries removed the cheese rather than buy refrigeration.

Pick One and Bake It This Weekend

Grab a sheet pan, a block of aged provolone and an open mind, and start with the Ohio Valley pie above. Then tell us in the comments which regional style your town claims, especially if it’s one nobody outside the county has heard of. If you want a forgiving crust for any of these, our pizza crust types explained guide helps you pick the right base.

Sources

  1. PMQ Pizza Magazine, Old Forge-style pizza is a cut above, Rick Hynum (2019), quoting Jim Mirabelli, Angelo Genell and Patrick Revello. pmq.com
  2. Wikipedia, Altoona-style pizza, citing the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and local press. en.wikipedia.org
  3. PMQ Pizza Magazine, Ohio Valley-style pizza, Liz Barrett Foster (2018), quoting Anna DiCarlo. pmq.com
  4. Beau Jo’s, Everything You Need to Know About Colorado Mountain Pie. beaujos.com
  5. PMQ Pizza Magazine, Why Colorado pizza lovers are so high on the Rocky Mountain Pie, Tracy Morin (2024), quoting Codi and Chip Bair. pmq.com
  6. Red Sauce America, The History of Rhode Island’s Pizza Strips. redsauceamerica.com

pinit fg en rect red 28

Zach Miller

Still deciding? These will help next:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *