Buffalo Style Pizza: What Makes It Different (and How to Make It at Home)

Regional Styles · Western New York

Buffalo Style Pizza: What Makes It Different (and How to Make It at Home)

Thick, airy base. Sweet sauce. Cheese out to the edge. And a carpet of little pepperoni cups holding pools of glorious grease.

Buffalo gave America the chicken wing, and the wing got all the credit. Meanwhile the city’s pizza sat quietly in the corner, piled with cheese, waiting for somebody outside Western New York to notice.

People are noticing now. Pizza writer Arthur Bovino called it “America’s most underappreciated regional style,” and once you see a Buffalo pie up close, the pitch makes sense. It’s not New York, it’s not Detroit, and it’s definitely not buffalo chicken pizza.

I’ve never eaten my way through Buffalo (my wallet and my cardiologist both thank me), so I did the next best thing. I read what the locals, the pizzerias and the trade press say actually defines the style, then built a home-oven recipe around those traits. Here’s what Buffalo pizza is, what makes it tick, and how to get close in your own kitchen.

Key Takeaways

  • Buffalo-style is a cup-and-char pepperoni pie. Small, natural-casing pepperoni that curls into crispy cups is the signature.
  • The crust sits in the middle. Thicker and airier than New York, lighter than Sicilian or Chicago deep dish, baked as a big round pie.
  • Sauce runs sweet, cheese runs heavy. Toppings go all the way to the edge, sometimes over it, with almost no bare rim.
  • It’s cut into squares. Round pie, square slices. Locals don’t blink at this.
  • It is not buffalo chicken pizza. No hot sauce, no ranch. Just pepperoni, cheese and attitude.

What Is Buffalo Style Pizza?

Buffalo style pizza is the regional pie of Buffalo, New York: a round pizza with a medium-thick, airy crust, a sweet tomato sauce, a heavy layer of mozzarella and a top layer of small pepperoni that cups and chars in the oven. It’s usually cut into squares.

The best one-line description comes from Bovino, quoted in PMQ Pizza Magazine: a cup-and-char pepperoni pizza with a slim, sometimes barely-there crust edge, toppings out to and over the rim, a thick and airy underside with little structural integrity, a sweet sauce, and enough cheese to nearly guarantee a cheese pull. That’s the whole style in one breath.

Quick clarification, because search engines get confused too. Buffalo style pizza has nothing to do with buffalo chicken pizza. The chicken version uses hot sauce and ranch. The Buffalo version is a pepperoni pie that happens to come from the same city as the wing.

The Five Traits That Define It

1. A crust that lives in the middle

Buffalo pizzerias describe their crust as a deliberate in-between. Bocce Club Pizza told WIVB News 4 that the style is known for a thick crust that’s crispy outside and chewy inside, more substantial than a thin, floppy New York slice. La Nova’s general manager called it “kind of in the middle” between thick and thin.

Visit Buffalo Niagara’s Patrick Kaler pitches it as a cross between New York and Chicago. If you’ve read our thin crust vs thick crust breakdown, Buffalo plants its flag right on the border and refuses to pick a side.

2. Sweet sauce, and plenty of it

Most sources agree the sauce leans sweet, though a few locals argue for spicy. Imperial Pizza calls its house sauce sweet and tangy, and Bocce Club’s gets a hint of heat. Tasting Table describes a semisweet sauce that cuts the richness of all that cheese and pepperoni.

That sweetness isn’t an accident. Sugar balances tomato acidity, which matters when you’re pairing it with fatty, salty pepperoni. At home, a teaspoon or two of sugar in a simple uncooked sauce gets you there.

3. Cheese to the edge (and then some)

Buffalo pies are loaded. Tasting Table, citing PMQ, called the mozzarella amount “borderline overkill,” and the toppings run right to the rim. There’s almost no naked crust edge on a proper Buffalo pie.

Whole-milk mozzarella is the local default. La Nova’s GM told WIVB that many Buffalo shops use it, and some, like Imperial, blend in provolone. Our guide to the best cheese blend ratios for pizza covers how provolone changes the melt and the flavor.

4. Cup-and-char pepperoni

This is the headliner. Small-diameter, natural-casing pepperoni shrinks unevenly in the heat, so each slice curls into a little cup with crispy, almost bacon-like edges and a pool of seasoned fat in the middle. PMQ’s visit with Ezzo Sausage Co. describes the slices curling into small cups that hold their juices while the edges turn crispy.

We went deep on the why and the where-to-buy in our guide to cup and char pepperoni. Short version: thin slices of a narrow stick, laid edge to edge, no overlapping.

5. Round pie, square cut

Here’s the quirk that throws visitors. Chowhound notes Buffalo pies are baked round like New York pizza but often cut into squares or rectangles. The center pieces have no crust at all, which some people consider the prize and others consider a crime.

New York soul, Detroit-level cheese, and a pepperoni cup on every square inch. Buffalo didn’t pick a lane. It built a new one.

Buffalo vs New York vs Detroit vs Chicago

Bovino describes Buffalo pizza as having a New York City soul with Detroit-level cheese. USA Today’s Larry Olmsted, quoted in the same PMQ piece, said it’s closest to Detroit but made as a large round pie like New York. Here’s how the four stack up on the traits that matter.

StyleShape and cutCrustSauceCheeseSignature
BuffaloRound, cut in squaresMedium-thick, airy, soft undersideSweet, generousHeavy whole-milk mozzarella to the edgeCup-and-char pepperoni
New YorkRound, cut in wedgesThin, foldableThin layerModerateThe fold
DetroitRectangular steel panThick, fried edgesLadled on topBrick cheese to the pan wallCaramelized cheese crown
Chicago deep dishRound, tall panButtery, tall sidesChunky, on topThick layer under the sauceKnife-and-fork depth

If you’re weighing which of these to try first, our overview of popular pizza styles covers the bigger family tree, and the New York vs Neapolitan comparison explains where the thin-crust branch came from.

Anatomy of a Buffalo Slice

Buffalo style pizza, top to bottomCup-and-char pepperonismall, natural casing, edge to edgeHeavy cheese, all the way outwhole-milk mozzarella, maybe provoloneSweet, generous saucebalances the salty pepperoniMedium-thick, airy crustchewy inside, between NY and ChicagoCrisp, golden bottomfrom an oiled pan on a low rackBarely any bare rim: toppings go to the edge

Traits compiled from Bocce Club Pizza and La Nova via WIVB, Arthur Bovino via PMQ and Buffalo Spree, Imperial Pizza and Tasting Table. Layer thickness is illustrative, not measured.

A Short History and Who Makes It Best

Nobody owns the invention. The style grew out of Buffalo’s Italian-American pizzerias in the mid-20th century, and the oldest name in most conversations is Bocce Club Pizza, which has served pies since 1946. La Nova on West Ferry Street followed in 1957.

The density of the scene is wild. PMQ reports that Buffalo has more than 600 pizza restaurants, with Bovino estimating 573 of them are independently owned, and that SmartAsset ranked Buffalo the second-best city for pizza lovers in 2017, ahead of New York. Every Buffalonian has a pizzeria they’ll defend harder than a Bills fan defends a fourth-down call.

Want a starting list? Buffalo Spree’s food editor rounded up 36 local pizzerias serving the hometown style, from Bocce Club and La Nova to Imperial, Santora’s, Carbone’s and Lovejoy. One piece of universal advice from Bovino: eat it fresh out of the oven, because a Buffalo pie doesn’t improve sitting in a delivery box.

Buffalo isn’t the only American city with a pie nobody outside town talks about. If you like underdog regional styles, check out our take on St. Louis-style pizza and the sauce-on-top Trenton tomato pie.

Tips for Nailing It at Home

Buy the right pepperoni. Look for a narrow stick labeled natural casing, and slice it thin. Wide, pre-sliced deli pepperoni lies flat and sad. Our explainer on what pepperoni is made of covers casings.

Shred your own cheese. Bagged shreds carry anti-caking starch that fights the melt. Here’s how to shred mozzarella without wrecking your knuckles.

Use a dark round pan. A dark, oiled 14-inch pan gives the crisp bottom and airy middle. Our roundup of pizza pans for home ovens covers good options.

Sweeten the sauce lightly. Start with 2 teaspoons of sugar per cup of tomatoes and taste. You want rounder, not candy.

A bit of sugar in the dough helps browning too, which is handy in a home oven that can’t hit pizzeria temperatures. Our piece on what sugar does in pizza dough explains the trade-offs. And for more pepperoni wisdom, our pro tips for pepperoni pizza are worth a skim before you shop.

The Recipe

Buffalo Style Pepperoni Pizza (Home Oven, 14-Inch Pan)

This is a home-oven take on the Western New York pie: an airy pan crust, sweet sauce, a heavy blanket of whole-milk mozzarella and a full layer of cupping pepperoni, cut into squares. I built it from the traits Buffalo pizzerias describe rather than any shop’s secret formula, and I haven’t baked it against the real thing, so treat the bake time as your starting line. It feeds four hungry people, or two people and one Bills game.

  • Star ingredient: small, natural-casing cup-and-char pepperoni
  • Flavor: sweet, salty, cheesy, crisp-edged
  • Best for: game day, Friday night, feeding a crowd
  • Difficulty: easy, mostly waiting on the dough
Prep25 min
Rise3 hr
Cook16–20 min
Total3 hr 45 min
Oven500°F
MakesOne 14-inch pie

Dough

  • 3¼ cups (400 grams) bread flour
  • 1 cup plus 1 tablespoon (250 grams) lukewarm water
  • 1½ teaspoons fine sea salt
  • 2 teaspoons sugar
  • 2 teaspoons olive oil, plus 2 tablespoons for the pan
  • ¾ teaspoon instant yeast

Sweet Sauce

  • 1 cup canned crushed tomatoes
  • 2 teaspoons sugar, to taste
  • ½ teaspoon dried oregano
  • ¼ teaspoon garlic powder
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil

Toppings

  • 12 ounces whole-milk low-moisture mozzarella, shredded from a block (about 3 cups)
  • Optional: swap 2 ounces of the mozzarella for provolone
  • 4 ounces small-diameter natural-casing pepperoni, sliced about ⅛ inch thick

Why bread flour? Its higher protein builds the chewy, airy structure Buffalo crusts are known for. Why whole-milk mozzarella? It melts creamier than part-skim, and it’s what many Buffalo shops use.

Instructions

  1. Mix the flour, salt, sugar and yeast in a large bowl. Add the water and 2 teaspoons oil and stir until no dry flour remains. Knead 6 to 8 minutes until smooth and slightly tacky.
  2. Cover and let rise at room temperature about 2 hours, until roughly doubled and bubbly.
  3. Pour 2 tablespoons olive oil into a dark 14-inch round pan and spread it to the edges. Press the dough out toward the edges. If it springs back, rest it 15 minutes and press again.
  4. Cover the pan and let the dough proof about 1 hour, until puffy and jiggly. Meanwhile, heat the oven to 500°F with a rack in the lowest position, and stir the sauce ingredients together. Taste: it should be gently sweet, not sugary.
  5. Spread the sauce over the dough almost to the edge, using about ¾ cup. Scatter the cheese all the way to the pan wall.
  6. Lay the pepperoni over the top edge to edge, touching but not overlapping. Coverage is the point.
  7. Bake 16 to 20 minutes, until the cheese is bubbling with golden spots, the pepperoni has curled into dark-edged cups, and the bottom is deep golden when you lift an edge with a spatula.
  8. Rest 3 minutes in the pan, slide onto a board, and cut into squares with a long knife or rocker. Eat immediately, the way Buffalo intended.

Tips: If the top browns before the bottom crisps, move the pan to the floor of the oven for the last 3 minutes. If the pepperoni won’t cup, it’s probably too wide or too thick, so go thinner next time.

Variation: Do it La Nova-style and brush the outer edge with garlic oil and a sprinkle of sesame seeds before baking, or add a few dollops of sweet sauce on top of the cheese for a stripier, saucier look.

Pull it out, listen to the cheese sizzle, and try not to burn the roof of your mouth. You will. Everyone does.

FAQ

What makes Buffalo style pizza different from New York style?

Buffalo crust is thicker and airier, the sauce is sweeter, the cheese is heavier and runs to the edge, and the pepperoni is the small cupping kind. It’s often cut into squares instead of wedges.

Is Buffalo style pizza the same as buffalo chicken pizza?

No. Buffalo style is a regional pepperoni pizza from Buffalo, New York. Buffalo chicken pizza is a topping combo built on hot sauce, chicken and ranch or blue cheese, and you can make it on any crust style.

What pepperoni do Buffalo pizzerias use?

Small-diameter, natural-casing pepperoni that curls into cups as it bakes. Brands vary by shop, and Ezzo is a well-known pizzeria supplier of cup-and-char slices. At home, any narrow natural-casing stick sliced thin will cup.

Why is Buffalo pizza cut into squares?

It’s a local habit rather than a rule, and plenty of shops cut wedges too. Squares make a big, heavily topped round pie easier to share, and the crustless center pieces have their own fan club.

Can I make Buffalo style pizza on a pizza stone?

You can, by stretching the dough a little thicker than a New York pie and launching it onto a hot stone. A dark oiled pan is closer to the airy, crisp-bottomed base, though, and it holds the extra cheese without drama.

Bring Buffalo Home This Weekend

Grab a skinny pepperoni stick, a block of whole-milk mozzarella and a dark round pan, and give this pie a Sunday. Then tell us in the comments whether you cut it in squares like a local or wedges like a rebel. Planning a game day spread? Our guide to pizza and football Sunday has the rest of the menu covered.

Sources

  1. PMQ Pizza Magazine, Why Buffalo-Style Should Be at the Top of Every Pizza Nerd’s Bucket List (2018), quoting Arthur Bovino and Larry Olmsted. pmq.com
  2. WIVB News 4, What is Buffalo-style pizza?, with Bocce Club Pizza and La Nova. wivb.com
  3. Buffalo Spree, Buffalo-style pizza you love, Christa Glennie (2024), quoting Arthur Bovino’s Buffalo Everything. buffalospree.com
  4. Tasting Table, What Makes Buffalo-Style Pizza Unique? tastingtable.com
  5. Chowhound, What Makes Buffalo-Style Pizza A Must-Try Regional Classic. chowhound.com
  6. PMQ Pizza Magazine, The Pizza Kitchen: Ezzo Sausage Co. pmq.com
  7. Imperial Pizza, A Slice of Buffalo History: The Evolution of Imperial Pizza. imperialpizzabuffalo.com

pinit fg en rect red 28

Zach Miller

Still deciding? These will help next:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *